This is about telling which album you feel has a best Beatles-defining touch to it? Which one represents most of the Beatles' main characteristics? Which album you think defines the Beatles best?

Although my favorite album is The White Album, I think that the album that shows more of what the Beatles really were is... hard to choose. I don't know, but I feel The White Album is more of an experience album, when they were testing all these new things in their songs, and it worked out wonderful.

But what the Beatles really were, what defines them most, I believe may be Abbey Road. But I'm not sure. I'll have to think about it a bit more.

I believe it's Abbey Road.  It shows many solid, clean recordings done by them, with great vocals from all, and orchestrations when needed and such, and at the end of the album, you see that all this is coming from four men with guitars and drums, as The End is just them all doing solos, and singing with great harmonies.  If I were to introduce someone to the Beatles, this album would do because it shows all the Beatles' strong points.

Rubber Soul. I think it showcases their musical sophistication while still being somewhat upbeat.

'Revolver'. It has everything and they were at their creative apex. From schmaltz to driving pop to what I think is John's Beatle masterpiece, "Tomorrow Never Knows". While other people were doing the frug and trying to catch up and copy what the Beatles were doing two years prior, John was hoisting out the Tibetan Book of the Dead, backwards stuff, compressed vocals. It was 1966 fer cryin' out loud. Incredible. The rest of the album is good too.

I'd say Revolver. As juniorsfarm said, it has a little bit of everything on it. There are traces of their earlier work to be found on the album, as well as hints at what was to come. It also showcases some of John and Paul's best songs, as well as some really good songs by George.

Revolver. Juniorsfarm said it all

Yeah, probably Revolver and for most of junior's reasons.

The odd thing is, if I had to choose a second one that best represented them I'd probably pick Help! which sounds nothing like Revolver.

i'd say abbey road. it has a little bit of each of them, and it just shows their total creativity.

BTW Lostio good thread!


I would go with Abbey Road, like sexy sadie said it does show their creativity

This is a VERY interesting question. And I found I couldn't answer it directly.

But I asked myself, which albums show the Fabs repeating themselves, or not exhibbiting their famous creativity? I found that easier to answer - here they are: the "plodding" Beatles albums:

With The Beatles - to some extent, but not much.
Help - certainly. Some folk would put Beatles For Sale here too.
Abbey Road (yeah, here I go again: but honestly, people pump this album far too much)
Let It Be

So that leaves PPM, AHDN, Rubber Soul, Revolver, Pepper and White as the answer to Lostio's question. So many albums - but THAT'S why the Beatles are so great.

Hmm... Abbey Road is my choice... Why? First off, it's where the studio is located that they recorded for most of their career, so it highlights that... It's go so many moods from each of the Beatles, George's first hit, Ringo's underwater adventure, and of course all the Lennon/McCartney hits... And the medley...

If you look at what the Beatles were and what everyone else was around them, you'd see that the Beatles had the most musical quality in their music. This album highlights that... It was what they were all about... Just making great sounding music...

And I can even boil it down to one single song: The End... It has everything... A great solo from Ringo, an awesome three way guitar showdown between the main guys... a highlight of the harmonizing skills of George, John and Paul, and of course, a great song!

And not to mention, probably, the most important lyric the Beatles ever put out... the boiling point of all of their music: "And in the end... the love you take, is equal to the love you make..." Such an important and seemingly overlooked (by everyone other than true beatle fans!) lyric... Who wrote that? Paul?

Anyway, I don't think anyone could ever replicate such an amazing album... I haven't really heard any... This album, I can listen to all the time all the way through... And it may be one of the few I can do that with...

I Want You is my all-time favorite Lennon song! Ah! I just love blasting it in the car while waiting in the parking lot for someone or at a red light with the windows down! That end! So climactic! Gotta love it!

2 thumbs up from me!

Quoted from Sie_Liebt_Dich

BTW Lostio good thread!

Thanks.

I think all albums represent a little of what the Beatles were and Abbey Road puts it all in one. My main choice would be either Abbey Road or Revolver.

Abbey Road has their style (You Never Give Me Your Money, Maxwell's Silver Hammer), their ballads (Something, Here Comes the Sun - George has the credit in this case), their rockers (She Came In Through the Bathroom Window, I Want You), and some still upbeat (Come Together).

Maybe Revolver would supere Abbey Road, because it also has the psychadelia effect, which was a big part of their career.

It does still have their style/creativity (Eleanor Rigby, Got To Get You Into My Life), ballads (Here There and Everywhere, For No One), heavier rockers (And Your Bird Can Sing, She Said She Said), and the psychadelia (Tomorrow Never Knows, I'm Only Sleeping), a bit of their still upbeat (Taxman, Doctor Robert) and some of the outside-influenced songs (Love You To).

But I think that Abbey Road represents what the Beatles actually were: a creative upbeat band, which could be soft enough to make ballads and rough enough to make rockers. Revolver maybe resumes more of what the Beatles DID, and not what they actually stood for and represented. So, therefore, I'd pick either Abbey Road or Revolver.

'Revolver' is my favorite album, but i'm not choosing it. I suppose i'll go with the 'White Album' for the diversity. Almost every type of musical styles are represented here, and I think thats what the Beatles are most remembered for. If ever there was a band that threw the listening public curve balls, it was the Beatles.

Its a tough question all the way around. No other artist or group progressed as quickly  and dramatically as the Beatles and each album has them doing their best stuff from that time period, and they did it without ever embarrasing themselves, unlike, say, the Stones with their foray into psychedelia with 'Stanic Majesties Request'. 'Rubber Soul' was them at their best in 1965, 'Revolver', 'Pepper', they just grew and developed so quickly and substantially in such a short amount of time. To go from 'Love Me Do' to 'Helter Skelter' in 6 years is mind boggling.

Though not my personal favourite, I'd go for A Hard Days Night. The sheer rush of Beatlemania, the mastery of the pop song, the ballsy optimism.
Like everyone I tend to concentrate on the later albums, because I guess they are a better listen. But I'm sure history will remember them more for Beatlemania than psychedelia.