Wonderful Christmas Time or Happy Xmas (War Is Over)

[Jema]

My favorite from these songs are Wonderful Christmas Time because I really like the way it sounds and it reminds me of Christmas.I also really love Happy Xmas (War Is Over) because I think it's really pretty and I really like the way that John and Yoko's voices sound in it.Overall it's just a beautiful song.Which one do you like better?

[nimrod]

Much prefer the Lennon one myself, I think Pauls is quite poor

[KelMar]

I think John's contribution to the holiday season is better too.

[Bobber]

A typical season bound poll.

[Normandie]

My vote goes to "Happy Xmas (War Is Over)" -- not only do I simply like the song better, but I can never get that darn refrain from "Wonderful Christmastime" out of my head!!!


(arrrrrgggggghhhhhhhh.............) 

[KelMar]

My vote goes to "Happy Xmas (War Is Over)" -- not only do I simply like the song better, but I can never get that darn refrain from "Wonderful Christmastime" out of my head!!!


(arrrrrgggggghhhhhhhh.............) 

I had a desktop theme that played that line with "simply having a" ahead of it when my computer booted up and I had to get rid of it for that very reason!

[Hello Goodbye]

They're both nice songs.  I like Wonderful Christmas Time just a bit better.

[nimrod]

They're both nice songs.  I like Wonderful Christmas Time just a bit better.

your just McCartney mad Barry  ha2ha

[Hello Goodbye]

I reckon. 

[Mr Mustard]

They ARE both very good I think, but I do prefer John & Yoko's "Happy Xmas (War Is Over)".

Think what you like but I even like George's New Year "Ding Dong Ding Dong" from the very end of '74

But I must admit I struggle with Ringo's "I Wanna Be Santa Claus"  ;sorry

[KelMar]

But I must admit I struggle with Ringo's "I Wanna Be Santa Claus"  ;sorry

I must have missed that one. Guess I'll have to look for it to see what you mean....maybe? 

[AppleScruffy96]

I choose Happy Xmas because of the meaning and the beautiful melody  ;yes plus I always listen to it every Christmas with my favorite aunt, she's an old hippie and loves John 

[Ovi]

I voted for "Wonderful Christmas", but I think they're both good songs. I also like The Beatles' "Chrstmas Time (Is Here Again)".

[nimrod]

I reckon. 

ha2ha

actually Pauls is very catchy and John mightve 'borrowed' that verse melody)

[Bobber]

ha2ha

actually Pauls is very catchy and John mightve 'borrowed' that verse melody)

mightve? He DID borrow it!