DM's Beatles forums
Solo forums => Paul McCartney => Topic started by: Beatlesrlove on June 13, 2011, 06:44:57 PM
-
Why wasn't this song ever released :o
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eyet4WxAmpM) It's such a great sweet song :)
-
sorry if you aren't able too see the video
Paul Mccartney-Goodbye (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eyet4WxAmpM#)
-
mary hopkin released it,didn't she?paul produced.so it did get released,just not sung by paul.
-
Yeah but I still think Paul should have Released it to though.
-
I never liked it very well to be honest. Might have been a good call on Pauls part.
-
Paul sung the Song in 1969 an give away for Mary you can Heard a version many Boots .
-
Why wasn't this song ever released :o
It's such a great sweet song :)
mary hopkin released it,didn't she?paul produced.so it did get released,just not sung by paul.
It's a sweet song for sure, but Paul wrote it for Mary Hopkin to record in early 1969. It charted well here in the United States and even better in the UK.
Mary Hopkin Goodbye (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mKgu8etXXcQ#ws)
We're fortunate to have Paul's demo.
-
We're fortunate to have Paul's demo.
Yeah, I have to agree, Paul's demo is better than her actual version, imo. And lets be honest, the best part of that video is watching Paul coach her through it lol!
-
Yeah, I have to agree, Paul's demo is better than her actual version, imo. And lets be honest, the best part of that video is watching Paul coach her through it lol!
I like Paul's demo very much too, but this was a terrific follow-up hit after her debut single Those Were The Days.
Yeah, Paul was fun to watch in the video!
-
Yeah ha2ha ha2ha
-
Paul McCartney Goodbye, White Album Outtake by Stevie Riks (MrSTEVIERIKS) (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Uy_l_75As8#)
-
I think it's a good song, but best for Mary Hopkins. But it definitely sounds like Paul. I've played this for people before and not told them anything about it, and they've asked me if McCartney wrote it.