DM's Beatles forums
Beatles forums => Albums => Topic started by: Rowdy on June 13, 2004, 10:40:53 AM
-
So far, The Beatles have fixed three areas of their catalogue. First, there was the Yellow Submarine Songtrack, which helped give the fans a Beatles album rather than a few songs with orchestral music attached to the end. The next problem in the band's catalogue was the lack of a decent hits release as the red and blue albums could have more songs and such.....in comes a full length CD, 1. And then of course, the band fixed in my opinion their weakest album, Let It Be, with LIB...Naked. So, of these three releases, which was the most substantial improvement on a previous release?
For me, the biggest improvement was undoubledly the new version of Let It Be. The improved sound quality and stronger sounding mixes made it feel like a Beatles album rather than the rough patchwork full of "Dig Its" and "Maggies" that we had earlier. Plus, we were finally rid of that awful orchestral score on "The Long and Winding Road".
-
out of those I like the Yellow Submarine Soundtrack the best.
-
YS. It was 'new' in its approach to the mixes, much clearer (tho there were some very bad mixing errors).
1 sounded like crap.
LIBN was impressive for the improved sound, yes, but there again too many missing elements. And LAWR never suffered from Spector's production...it was the kind of song that just begged for the bathos approach.
-
I havent heard the reissue of YS yet, but '1' and Naked didnt impress me.
-
[quote by=tkitna link=Blah.pl?b=albums,m=1087123253,s=3 date=1087256128]I havent heard the reissue of YS yet, but '1' and Naked didnt impress me.[/quote]
What about the "Fly on the Wall" bonus disc? That was truly an amazing listen....I mean, wow!.......
yeah, I've only listened to it once.
-
It was ok, but i've got christmas cd's and such that are far better.
-
I don't know, I've always had this slight dislike of Let it Be, which I'm trying to correct by listening to ...Naked - it did help a bit, I think. I now find I'm able to tolerate The long and winding road, and the songs sounds crisper to my ears. Not to mention I think the design for Naked is much better (I'm a Media student, so these things influence me) So all in all, it's an improvement :)
-
Yes to YS.
-
[quote by=misterchaz link=Blah.pl?b=albums,m=1087123253,s=2 date=1087141271]YS.
-
Let it be...Naked
-
I like Let it Be Naked.. merely because Im in the Mccartney Camp in reference to the Spector input issues.
-
Yellow Sub, I don't really like Let it Be Naked... meh.
-
LIBN....it just sounds incredible, i cant get enough of it. Huge improvement imo
-
Hmm. Yellow Submarine was really well-done. Except for I miss John's little "...igh,ah,igh..." mess-up in Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds. And Baby, You're a Rich Man is fantastic there, too. It sounds full and...right.
And the Long and Winding Road from Let it Be...Naked is a REEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLY great improvement. Some of the weird things Paul does when he's singing...it actually makes sense without that grotty orchestra packed in. Not that i'm against orchestras, it just didn't fit in very well with -that- song.
-
Tough one....
1 was poorly done, which I think we all agree on.
Let It Be (Naked) featured the Long & Winding Road as its composer intended, so that was a big plus, however, I liked the live feel of the orginal album, which the new version loses. On the strength of the correction of the torture that Spector put us through, I voted for Let It Be - Naked.
-
Newbee here!
This is my first post but I was very impressed with YSS, particularly with the technology that allows the individual elements of the original recordings to be seperated and then re-mixed. IMHO the results are a significant improvement on the original mixes and I cannot help wanting to hear all the Beatles albums, particularly the early four track recordings, being given the same treatment. I know that this is a controversial point of view and many consider the original mixes should not be altered.
-
[quote by=Rowdy link=Blah.pl?b=albums,m=1087123253,s=0 date=1087123253]For me, the biggest improvement was undoubledly the new version of Let It Be. The improved sound quality and stronger sounding mixes made it feel like a Beatles album rather than the rough patchwork full of "Dig Its" and "Maggies" that we had earlier. Plus, we were finally rid of that awful orchestral score on "The Long and Winding Road".[/quote]
Hey.... I like "Dig It"!
But... even though I've never seen the Yellow Submarine Songtrack CD, I've heard of it, and I think it's a brilliant idea. That's my idea of what the LP should have been. Instead of those tiring instrumental tracks. With all due respect to the great George Martin, they don't really have place on a Beatles' album.
-
I liked Let it Be naked, it just sounds better, on the original you get a production which is just sickly, in my opinion far to too much. The original versions of things like across the universe just sound wrong compared to the "new version"
-
Yellow Submarine Songtrack
I'm a little suprised to see Let It Be Naked in the lead. I'm still a bit burned with the exclusion of previous songs from that one. I also liked the orchestration on the...never mind, that's probably a whole different subject.
-
Let It Be...Naked
-
I really like how they fixed up Baby Your A Rich Man on the Yellow Sub Songtrack, the vocals are so much more clear.
-
^One of my favourite ones ... ever!
-
LIBN and YSS are tied for me, They we're both mixed using the same process (pro tools) and engineers.
1 on the other hand gives you 24 bit remastering, which, although clearer than the 80's CD's had already been used on the red and blue compilations, so it's not anywhere near being in the same league as the other two.