DM's Beatles forums
Beatles forums => Polls => Topic started by: ShesCominDownFastYesSheIs on May 11, 2008, 02:40:45 AM
-
seemed like a good idea for a poll. three of Paul's most acclaimed songs. and they're all very similar. Paul is the only Beatle to appear (not counting John and George's brief harmonies on the "Lonely People" line) and they all run just a little over two minutes.
I've always thought Eleanor Rigby was one of their greatest songs, so I voted for that. but Blackbird is brilliant in it's simplicity (great riff too!) and Yesterday.....well what can I say that hasn't already been said?
-
Rigby>Blackbird>>>>>>>>>>>>yesterday
-
Blackbird>Rigby>Yesterday
-
I said ER because I like Paul's accent :P
-
Yesterday>Eleanor Rigby>Blackbird
-
Yesterday real nice song then blackbird, and then eleanor rigby.
If Mother Nature's Son was on then I would've voted for that
-
Blackbird no one doe's these little acoustic songs better than Paul (clap)
-
i vote junk :)
-
Elanor Rigby, then Yesterday, and last Blackbird.
-
Blackbird>Rigby>Yesterday
That's it, I think. :)
-
^^Agreed!
-
Eleanor Rigby, then Yesterday, and last Blackbird.
I love the sound and story behind ER, great song alot of emotion.
Yesterday of course one of his greatest, probably is. I still prefer to hear ER though.
Blackbird, great song. Just my least favorite out of the three.
-
Rigby>Blackbird>>>>>>>>>>>>yesterday
same here
-
Yesterday>BlackBird>Eleanor Rigby
-
all 3 brilliant pieces of work in my book, but Yesterday really takes it for me! still gets me everytime.
we all know the story but it's a georgeous song sung & wrote so beautifully! masterpiece & so memorable! :)
-
1. 'Blackbird'
2. 'Yesterday'
3. 'Eleanor Rigby'
Never been all that fond of 'ER'. Too 'down' for me, though I appreciate the quality of the songwriting.
:-/
-
Eleanor Rigby, then Yesterday, and then Blackbird
-
Yesterday!
-
Eleanor Rigby for me.
-
Blackbird
-
1. Blackbird (probably my favourite Beatles song, though it might be tied w/ Here There & Everywhere)
2. Eleanor Rigby
3. Yesterday
-
'Here, There And Everywhere', 'Penny Lane' and 'For No One' are better than all three, but...
1. Eleanor Rigby
2. Yesterday
3. Blackbird