DM's Beatles forums
Solo forums => John Lennon => Topic started by: Wayne L. on August 16, 2006, 02:00:19 PM
-
I think John should have released the live track Well(Baby Please Don't Go) as a single from Sometime In NYC. I believe it would have been a top 10 song & the album would have possibly made the top five at the time. WBPDG is a great song with the late, great Frank Zappa that I put with his performance in Toronto back in 69. Thanks to You Tube I also got to see the classic performance which I thought didn't exist. You had Led Zeppelin, Black Sabbath, Grand Funk & Deep Purple conquering the rock scene & Well(Baby Please Don't Go) is just as ballsy & blistering. STINYC wouldn't have been slightly ignored by fans like it was in those days, because of Lennon's radical left lyrics, even though the tracks are excellent, if this would have been the single.
-
the version from 'live jam' with zappa on sometime in NYC is pretty awful, unrehearsed, badly recorded, an actual poor band performance, john and yoko were on Coke at the time, and yoko's howling makes it even worse..it would not have been a big hit at all, if anything it could have damaged john and franks musical careers.....however, you should check out the version on wonsaponatime & anthology (john's), which is alright.
-
the version from 'live jam' with zappa on sometime in NYC is pretty awful, unrehearsed, badly recorded, an actual poor band performance, john and yoko were actually on Coke at the time, and yoko's howling makes it even worse..it would not have been a big hit at all, if anything it could have damaged john and franks musical careers.....however, you should check out the version on wonsaponatime & anthology (john's), which is alright.
I don't know what you have been smoking, but it must be stronger than weed. Well(Baby Plase Don't Go) is a great ballsy live track with John & Zappa, I don't give a damn about Yoko's performance. I will listen to those other Lennon albums, when I get the chance, but you're insane to hate that song.
-
he never said hate wayne.....
-
I did. I hate it and it sucks. Lennonlegend was right. I dont find the NYC version appealing at all. How sloppy can a song be?
-
I did. I hate it and it sucks. Lennonlegend was right. I dont find the NYC version appealing at all. How sloppy can a song be?
Careful T. Only one opinion counts, and I guess you must be insane as well.
-
I hear ya Sally. I'm just waiting for the onslaught as I disagreed.
-
he never said hate wayne.....
right on, and yeh its as sloppy as anything.
-
I hear ya Sally. I'm just waiting for the onslaught as I disagreed.
You're the one that gives the onslaught baby & I don't care if you disagree at all, but of course, you probably have never the track or the album anyway.
-
right wayne, thats why he says that he heard it and it sounded like crap. see, he comes off as a beatles lover and one that knows alot about them but in reality he makes this up and is a die-hard micheal bolton fan.
-
Being sarcastic as usual somedude210? I've been harassed on this site, no matter what I say, but I'm a dedicated Beatles fan as well, even though that doesn't matter here. I think Well(Baby Please Don't Go) is a great live track from STINYC & I'm just giving my opinion, but some saying it's pretty awful is crazy.
-
no, its another OPINION, just like yours ok? just because someone doesnt agree with you doesn't mean theyre crazy, and well with you being you, they're also proberly right....now thats not harrassment alright? just me stating a fact..get over you're sulk then and lets discuss it properly.
-
well put. now if only he'd listen.
dear wayne,
my sarcasim is a way to respond to you with humor and wit. it is not in any way harrassing you nor was it intended to do so. if you are harrassed it is because you bring it on yourself. you make these threads or post something that someone is bound to disagree with. you are misinformed sometimes and when someone tries to state fact or show you the error of your ways, you flip out at them and call them crazy or a liberal wacko/nutjob. we are not harrassing you as you may think, we are simply stating opposing opinions and try to ask you why you treat us like crap for doing so. i personally ask in a sarcastic tone. others may vary.
be kind and rewind,
somedude
-
I think I've endured the live album only once since I bought STINYC (that acronym is very close to STINK!!) - in my opinion it's barely listenable. But I actually like most of the studio tracks - even Yoko's!
The worst track in my opinion is Luck Of The Irish - the worst cliched lyrics I have EVER heard!
-
STINYC (that acronym is very close to STINK!!)--That's awesome Al (and true). "Luck of the Irish", come on, grab your blarney stone and chill.
-
"Luck of the Irish", come on, grab your blarney stone and chill.
LOL!! These lyrics in particular make me cringe...
If you could keep voices like flowers
There'd be shamrock all over the world
If you could drink dreams like Irish streams
Then the world would be high as the mountain of morn
AND...
If we could make chains with the morning dew
The world would be like Galway Bay
Let's walk over rainbows like leprechauns
The world would be one big Blarney stone
So basically Yoko's bits! Those were probably her lyrics - no wonder John didn't want to sing them!
-
Yep. Doesn't get much worse than that. The great vocals don't help either. JL's 'Pick a cause, any cause' period didn't do much for him, and having Yoko bringing up the rear, really put an anchor around everything.
-
Yeah, it's really difficult to walk over a rainbow like a leprechaun when you're carrying an anchor - you end up falling through it and stubbing your big toe on the Blarney stone!! ;D