The 2nd Collection Poll

[Frightwolf]

The first one went by pretty well, so here's a follow-up:


The Lennon Collection:

1) I Am The Walrus
2) Strawberry Fields Forever
3) In My Life
4) Tomorrow Never Knows
5) You've Got to Hide Your Love Away
6) All You Need Is Love
7) Come Together
Across The Universe
9) If I Fell
10) No Reply
11) And Your Bird Can Sing
12) Help!
13) It Won't Be Long
14) Ticket to Ride
15) Twist and Shout


The McCartney Collection:

1) I Saw Her Standing There
2) Can't Buy Me Love
3) Yesterday
4) Got to Get You Into My Life
5) She's Leaving Home
6) Get Back
7) Let It Be
Penny Lane
9) Eleanor Rigby
10) For No One
11) The Long and Winding Road
12) We Can Work It Out
13) Hello Goodbye
14) Paperback Writer
15) Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight/The End

[number14]

The Mccartney collection easily, tounds better songs.

[Joost]

Let's use the song vs. song method here, OK?

I am the walrus - I saw here standing there: 1-0 for Lennon
Strawberry Fields forever - Can't buy me love: 2-0
In my life - Yesterday: 3-0
Tomorrow never knows - Got to get you into my life: 3-1
You've got to hide your love away - She's leaving home: 3-2 (veeeeeery close)
All you need is love - Get back: 3-3
Come together - Let it be: 3-4 (CT might be Lennon's, but what makes it so cool is McCartney's bassline)
Across the universe - Penny Lane: 4-5 (they both get points here cause I really can't choose)
Ticket to ride - Paperback writer: 4-6
Twist and shout - Medley: 4-6... no points cause Lennon cheated... Twist & shout is not his.

LOL! Can't get more objective than that, Bikkies!

[Soft_Guitar60]

here's mine:
I am the walrus-I saw her standing there: 1-0
Strawberry Fields forever - Can't buy me love: 2-0
In my life - Yesterday: 2-1
Tomorrow never knows - Got to get you into my life: 3-1
You've got to hide your love away - She's leaving home: 4-1 (it's not because i don't like paul! I love him!)
All you need is love - Get back: 4-2
Come together - Let it be: 4-3
Across the universe - Penny Lane: 4-4
Ticket to ride - Paperback writer: 4-5
Twist and shout - Medley: 5-5 (altough it's not from John. Just give the point)
Well, that's a tie...I can't pick...oh well, i'll choose John...lol

[Strawberryfields67]

The Lennon Collection by a miniscule bit.

[Rowdy]

Lennon > McCartney

EDIT: And just for kicks,

I am the walrus - I saw here standing there: 1-0
Strawberry Fields forever - Can't buy me love: 2-0
In my life - Yesterday: 3-0
Tomorrow never knows - Got to get you into my life: 4-0
You've got to hide your love away - She's leaving home: 5-0
All you need is love - Get back: 6-0
Come together - Let it be: 6-1
Across the universe - Penny Lane: 6-2
If I Fell - Eleanor Rigby: 6-3
No Reply - For No One: 6-4
And Your Bird Can Sing - Long and Winding Road: 7-4
Help - We Can Work It Out: 8-4
It Won't Be Long - Hello Goodbye: 9-4
Ticket to ride - Paperback writer: 10-4
Twist and shout - Medley: 10-5

[Frightwolf]

LoL, the song vs. song thing is nice, but there's a lot of song vs. song things that aren't similar songs.  Come Together vs. Let It Be? 

[number14]

I still think the mccartney collection is a ton better.

[Bruno]

The George collection

[Soft_Guitar60]

Put a George and Ringo collection...

[number14]

Let me do it in versus style

I am the walrus vs i saw her standing there    1-0
strawberry fields vs cant muy me love              1-1
In my life Vs yesterday                                     2-1           
tomorow never knows vs got to get you in my life 2-2
youve got to hide ur love away vs shes leaving home 2-3
All you need is love vs get back                          2-4
come together vs let it be                                  2-5
Across the univurse vs penny lane                    3-5
If i fell vs eleanor rigby                                      3-6
No reply vs for no one                                       3-7
And your bird can sing vs lwr                             4-7
Help vs we can work it out                                4-8
It wont be long vs hello goodbye                      4-9
Ticket to ride vs paperback writer                      4-10
Twist and shout vs medley                                 4-11

[SieLiebtDich]

Lennon collection

[sange]

Lennon Collection...only for the fact that it has three of my top 20 Beatles songs in it

(It won;t be long, And your bird can sing,  If I fell)

whereas the McCartney Collection has only one (paperback Writer)

[Will Campbell]

I'd take the Lennon collection.  There's a lot of substance there people.  (And that's coming from a McCartney fan...hell I even stood in for him during the 60's!)  LOL