But the thing is, the three other guys in Floyd felt so alienated by Waters. His ego completly took over. David was a stonger personality so he could handle it more, but the other guys couldn't. I think Roger is a genius, but that he needed the other guys to fully interpret his visions. That's why some bands make it and others don't. You need the perfect combination. And people keep mentioning the Wall movie. Roger didn't write it. Only the music. He wasn't the sole creator of it. I love Roger, but I think he needs to get a grip.