What ever happend to Sargent Peppers. In my mind its the 2nd best album that the Beatles put out. The only album beter is White . Who agrees with me?

Sorry.  For me Pepper would share #1 with Hard Day's Night, and White would be at the botome of the list.

Funny that, eh?  How many diverse opinions these guys engendered?

Quoted from misterchaz, posted March 5, 2004, 5:08pm at here

Sorry.  For me Pepper would share #1 with Hard Day's Night, and White would be at the botome of the list.

I agree entirely Mister C.
The White Album is hugely over-rated and it's fashionable to say Revolver is better than Pepper!
When people ask me for the best Beatles album I hesitate between Pepper and Hard Day's Night, but Pepper has got a song for Ringo which gives it the edge!

I have to disagree with you about the White Album being hugely overrated... I think it is  brilliant! There are so many songs on that album that are truly classic songs. So many different styles on one album: few bands can beat that!

Pepper is in my opinion an overrated album! Just a few songs I really like on that album... Definitely not as many good songs as on the White Album.

But hey, I like Revolver too! I nearly like all Beatles' songs...


Marcel

I agree about Revolver being a great album . But Its only my 4th favorite. My third Being Rubber Soul . Hey how bout this, I'll set up a tread about favorite origional albmus in order. I'll talk about it there.

Pepper is definetely better tahn white album. White has some songs which i really don't like. But Revolver is better than Pepper. As for AHDN it's not as good as Pepper

Quoted from Marcel, posted March 5, 2004, 7:26pm at here

I have to disagree with you about the White Album being hugely overrated... I think it is  brilliant! There are so many songs on that album that are truly classic songs.

Marcel

What's a truly classic song?Yesterday?Something?Hey Jude?
On the White album there are some good songs, but not many classics.
Pepper, on the other hand is a classic album.If you take one song away it wouldn't be the same...Who cares if Honey Pie or Good Night or Don't Pass Me By had never existed?Not me...

Hi Zipp!

Are you the same Zipp who posts on the Les Yellow Sub forum? If so I was just wondering what everyone had to say about my Walrus King Lear post... I can't read French!

Quoted from zipp, posted March 6, 2004, 12:01am at here

What's a truly classic song?Yesterday?Something?Hey Jude?
On the White album there are some good songs, but not many classics.
Pepper, on the other hand is a classic album.If you take one song away it wouldn't be the same...Who cares if Honey Pie or Good Night or Don't Pass Me By had never existed?Not me...

The way I see it, a classic song is a song by the Beatles which is such a great song... I don't consider Hey Jude and Yesterday GREAT songs: Back In The USSR, Glass Onion, Helter Skelter, and many more of course are what I consider to be great songs. It's just my opinion that's all...

Oh and BTW: I love Honey Pie! It's a great song!


Marcel

I personally can't decide on a favourite Beatles album! It's too difficult! But, in saying that, Sgt. Peppers was my first album and I think it is truly amazing stuff. It got no. 1 album of all time in Rolling Stone...I have to agree with that.

Rolling Stone sucks.

hmm, each to their own ey, some of my personal favourites were listed, so i thought it wasn't too bad.

Yeah, some of my favorites, too, but a lot bad albums, and some albums should be higher/lower.

Oh i agree completely! Some of mine were so underrated, but I was still pleased they got a mention.

I think the highest Zeppelin album is on #29. o_O