Hurt I'll Follow The Sun
Heal Oh! Darling

All My Loving 10
And I Love Her 8
I'll Follow The Sun 8
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 11
She's Leaving Home 10
Fool On The Hill 11
I Will 10
Blackbird 11
Rocky Racoon 10
Let It Be 11
The Long and Winding Road 11
Two of Us 11
Oh! Darling 11

Ok, I was going through the game and people have either been not adding or subtracting a point, adding or subtracting two points, or adding more than one point for songs they didn't specify.

( Sorry, I can't help it, I can be incredibly anal!!! )  I have gone through this a few times and this *should* be the correct tally before I put my latest votes in.


All my loving 11
And i love her 8
Ill follow the sun 8
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 12
Shes leaving home 11
Fool on the hill 10
I will 9
Blackbird 13
Rocky Racoon 7
Let It Be 12
The long and winding road 7
Two Of Us 11
Oh! Darling 10


(A quick way of checking if things are on track - all the numbers should add up to 140)

So, to keep things going...

heal: oh! darling
hurt: the long and winding road

All my loving 11
And i love her 8
Ill follow the sun 8
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 12
Shes leaving home 11
Fool on the hill 10
I will 9
Blackbird 13
Rocky Racoon 7
Let It Be 12
The long and winding road 6
Two Of Us 11
Oh! Darling 11

haha, Im back Frightwolf!
Heal - And I Lover Her
Hurt Oh Darling



All my loving 11
And i love her 9
Ill follow the sun 8
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 12
Shes leaving home 11
Fool on the hill 10
I will 9
Blackbird 13
Rocky Racoon 7
Let It Be 12
The long and winding road 6
Two Of Us 11
Oh! Darling 10

Heal - And I Love Her
Hurt - Rocky Raccoon

All my loving 11
And i love her 10
Ill follow the sun 8
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 12
Shes leaving home 11
Fool on the hill 10
I will 9
Blackbird 13
Rocky Racoon 6
Let It Be 12
The long and winding road 6
Two Of Us 11
Oh! Darling 10

Heal And I Love Her
Hurt Two Of Us

All My Loving 10
And I Love Her 9
I'll Follow The Sun 9
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 11
She's Leaving Home 10
Fool On The Hill 11
I Will 10
Blackbird 11
Rocky Racoon 10
Let It Be 11
The Long and Winding Road 11
Two of Us 10
Oh! Darling 10

glad i got this down now

Heal All My Loving
Hurt The Long & Winding Road

All My Loving 11
And I Love Her 9
I'll Follow The Sun 9
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 11
She's Leaving Home 10
Fool On The Hill 11
I Will 10
Blackbird 11
Rocky Racoon 10
Let It Be 11
The Long and Winding Road 10
Two of Us 10
Oh! Darling 10

Heal I'll Follow The Sun
Hurt Fool On The Hill

All My Loving 11
And I Love Her 9
I'll Follow The Sun 10
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 11
She's Leaving Home 10
Fool On The Hill 10
I Will 10
Blackbird 11
Rocky Racoon 10
Let It Be 11
The Long and Winding Road 10
Two of Us 10
Oh! Darling 10

Heal And I Love Her
Hurt The Long and Winding Road

All My Loving 11
And I Love Her 10
I'll Follow The Sun 10
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 11
She's Leaving Home 10
Fool On The Hill 10
I Will 10
Blackbird 11
Rocky Racoon 10
Let It Be 11
The Long and Winding Road 9
Two of Us 10
Oh! Darling 10

Heal: Oh! Darling
Hurt: The long and winding road

All my loving 12
And i love her 11
Ill follow the sun 9
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 12
Shes leaving home 11
Fool on the hill 9
I will 9
Blackbird 13
Rocky Racoon 6
Let It Be 12
The long and winding road 4
Two Of Us 10
Oh! Darling 11

Quoted from Soft_Guitar60, posted December 18, 2004, 8:50pm at here

All My Loving 11
And I Love Her 10
I'll Follow The Sun 10
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 11
She's Leaving Home 10
Fool On The Hill 10
I Will 10
Blackbird 11
Rocky Racoon 10
Let It Be 11
The Long and Winding Road 9
Two of Us 10
Oh! Darling 10

Quoted from sange, posted December 18, 2004, 8:51pm at here

Heal: Oh! Darling
Hurt: The long and winding road

All my loving 12
And i love her 11
Ill follow the sun 9
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 12
Shes leaving home 11
Fool on the hill 9
I will 9
Blackbird 13
Rocky Racoon 6
Let It Be 12
The long and winding road 4
Two Of Us 10
Oh! Darling 11

Ahem?

Im confused, what's the real score for the songs now?

I suggest we start again. The correct amount of points so far would have been:

All My Loving 11
And I Love Her 10
I'll Follow The Sun 10
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 11
She's Leaving Home 10
Fool On The Hill 10
I Will 10
Blackbird 11
Rocky Racoon 10
Let It Be 11
The Long and Winding Road 8
Two of Us 10
Oh! Darling 11

And we started with 10 each. There is no way it is that amount of points that we've got in total here. Do the math.

LOL!!!!! Lostio, that "ahem" reply... LOL!

It looks like Sange had a bit too much fun changing the scores, ESPECIALLY on Long and Winding Road.

That's OK, we'll start from that score.

Hurt I'll Follow The Sun
Heal Oh! Darling

All My Loving 11
And I Love Her 10
I'll Follow The Sun 9
Yesterday 11
Eleanor Rigby 11
She's Leaving Home 10
Fool On The Hill 10
I Will 10
Blackbird 11
Rocky Racoon 10
Let It Be 11
The Long and Winding Road 8
Two of Us 10
Oh! Darling 12

Um, actually...

look at the difference between "soft guitar's" post (no 4 and Lostio's post (no 49).  I simply went back to soft guitar's and worked everyone's out from there.  Rocky Raccoon and Long and winding road went from both being at 6 points to ten and eleven! I think what might have happened was that Lostio may have posted and added/subtracted from the bottom of the first page of the post, rather than the end.  I only changed the score to what they really were, based on everyones hurt (subtract one) and heal (add one) vote. Or are we scoring differently?  If I have made a genuine mistake, I will happily say "sorry, I stuffed up" but I am not changing anything that wasn't voted for.  I love competition and am very competive by nature too, but I never cheat.  (Not even to get rid of Long and Winding Road)

And as for doing the maths, any time I changed it, I always made sure that the scores added up to 140.  The total will never change as long as we are still adding one, subtracting one.  Add it up from the last post...144, hmmmm

I know it's just a game, but the aim of it is to get songs eliminated, no? I was just trying to make sure it was happening properly. Like I said, I am pedantic about these things. I am sorry if I stepped on any toes here.  Please, go through all 60 posts and see where we come out.  The competition between the songs would not be so close as it is now.