Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Forum Login
Login Name: Create a new account
Password:     Forgot password

DM's Beatles forums    Solo forums    Fifth Beatles and Merseybeat  ›  Who's the 5th Beatle? Moderators: pc31

 Who is the undisputed 5th Beatle?
George Martin (32 votes)
59.26%
There is no 5th Beatle! (8 votes)
14.81%
Stu Sutcliffe (6 votes)
11.11%
Brian Epstein (5 votes)
9.26%
Neil Aspinall (2 votes)
3.70%
Mal Evans (1 votes)
1.85%
Yoko Ono (0 votes)
0%
54 Votes Total Last vote August 16, 2008, 11:12pm by Okay
You must login or register to be allowed to participate in this poll

Who's the 5th Beatle?  This thread currently has 3,688 views. Print
7 Pages « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 » All Recommend Thread
pc31
May 19, 2008, 10:32pm Report to Moderator

rockabilly rules!!!!!
Board Moderator
Posts
8,348
Gender
Male
Posts Per Day
5.07
ooops that was 39 he came out...my mom said he had a pompador like little richard in the 40s and thinks little richard stole his flambouyant style from him too...


Logged Offline
Site E-mail Private Message AIM YIM Windows Live Messenger Reply: 75 - 93
pc31
May 19, 2008, 10:36pm Report to Moderator

rockabilly rules!!!!!
Board Moderator
Posts
8,348
Gender
Male
Posts Per Day
5.07
you gotta go back to older jazz to really trace it to the roots...who were the jazzers b4 1940 sir william??


Logged Offline
Site E-mail Private Message AIM YIM Windows Live Messenger Reply: 76 - 93
pc31
May 19, 2008, 10:40pm Report to Moderator

rockabilly rules!!!!!
Board Moderator
Posts
8,348
Gender
Male
Posts Per Day
5.07
Big Band Swing
Though the appearance of Benny Goodman and his big band in 1935 at the Palomar Ballroom in Los Angeles is considered to be the "official" start of the Big Bands, the style had been brewing for over a decade, starting out in New Orleans as Dixieland jazz.

Swing became increasingly popular thanks in part to radio play of such legends as Louis Armstrong, Duke Ellington and Glenn Miller. The style of music and dance spreading from dancehall to dancehall on both coasts with variations of the swing dance appearing in different regions of the country like the Lindy hop and Jitterbug......then there were bluesmen...robert johnson...
i borrowed the gist of this...


Logged Offline
Site E-mail Private Message AIM YIM Windows Live Messenger Reply: 77 - 93
Bobber
May 20, 2008, 8:25am Report to Moderator

Administrator
Posts
7,531
Posts Per Day
6.44
Sure. But that music had an other origin as well. The Beatles' parents listened to a certain kind of music which influenced their offspring. You gotta start somewhere.


Logged Offline
Site Private Message Reply: 78 - 93
pc31
May 20, 2008, 9:43am Report to Moderator

rockabilly rules!!!!!
Board Moderator
Posts
8,348
Gender
Male
Posts Per Day
5.07
ok in the begininng there was light....


Logged Offline
Site E-mail Private Message AIM YIM Windows Live Messenger Reply: 79 - 93
alexis
June 7, 2008, 7:35pm Report to Moderator

Getting Better
Posts
786
Posts Per Day
1.38
Quoted from pc31
ok in the begininng there was light....


No, no, before that  

There were four elementary particles, that later joined to create space-time in a most harmonious sort of way  

The names of these four particles were ... :

1) ____________________
2) ____________________
3) ____________________
4) ____________________


I love John,
I love Paul,
And George and Ringo,
I love them all!

Alexis
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 80 - 93
alexis
June 7, 2008, 9:15pm Report to Moderator

Getting Better
Posts
786
Posts Per Day
1.38
Quoted from pc31
ok in the begininng there was light....


No, seriously ...

I love listening to the Andrews Sisters. No, wait, let me explain, please!

Andrews Sisters
They were a girl group from MN that sang in the 30's, 40's, 50's and probably beyond. They were 3 sisters that could harmonize INCREDIBLY. Like our boys, they were singing together since childhood, even earlier than John, Paul and George! Here is a clip to one of their most famous songs, "Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-wiVkdVPGoY

and here is another less famous one that shows off how much they can do with their voices - slurs, scat, etc. ... all in perfect 3-part harmony ("Hold Tight" )!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QSpTwzOs-E8

I like to imagine that there is a direct line from these queens of 3-part harmony, through the black girl groups and other groups of the 50's that the Beatles cut their teeth on when they were learning to sing, straight through to John, Paul, and George. I remember reading George or Paul said the first song they learned 3-part harmony to was the Teddy Bear's "To Know Him is to Love Him" *. Then there were the great harmonies of the Cookies, who did Chains ** , the Marvelletes who did "Please Mr. Postman", the Shirelles who did " Baby It's You" *** , and lots of others. The Beatles loved all of them, and recorded them almost unchanged from the original versions. Not a bad cover band, those Beatles!


* "To Know Him is to Love Him" - The Teddy Bears : That was a Phil Spector song, title based on his father's tombstone epitaph . Funny how the music business seems to work, with him almost 2 decades later producing (or overproducing, depending on your taste) their Let it Be album, and later producing one of John's hits, after brandishing a live pistol in the recording studio ("We do it my way, OK John?").  Here's an early version of "To Know Him is to Love Him" for some 50s TV show. Corny as can be, but I think this may be the very version that the 3 boys sat around and listened to, studied how to sing, and performed on stage, and ultimately at their Decca Audition! Just about note-for-note! You be the judge ... :

Phil Spector's version (is this actually him as one of the Teddy Bears?):


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DCnUsInBQws

^^ I have tears in my eyes as I watch this. Some young kids, all dressed up in borrowed studio fancy wear, helping set the course for music for decades to come. They don't even know it ... Back home to chores later that night, oh come on Dad, please can I go out tonight...

"To Know Him is to Love Him" - The Beatles And now the Beatles version:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbGsPapwKfg&feature=related


[Edited] And here's "To Know Him is to Love Him", Amy Winehouse doing the same tune!


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QAHdAVOiw6Q&feature=related


** "Chains",  The Cookies:

http://oldschoolmusiclover.wordpress.com/2008/05/05/chains-as-performed-by-the-cookies-1963/

Man, I swear I can hear Paul harmonizing right in there! Again, the Beatles didn't vary too much at all from the vocals. That makes me think they learned this song really early as well, when they were learning to do harmony ("let's learn it just like this, then we'll know how to do stuff like this, so we have a vocal base to explore from later" ... they probably never said).

Interestingly, Chains was written by Carole King (and her husband Gerry Goffin), who was one of John's and Paul's greatest song-writing idols in the late 50's and early '60s! "We want to be like them" they pretty much said in interviews. It was originally performed by The Cookies, who were the back up group to Carole King's babysitter ... otherwise known as Little Eva (of Little Eva and the Imperials). Carole King wrote her first hit, "Locomotion", inspired by Little Eva's singing and dancing, and had her sing the demo track. When it was presented to Don Kirschner, he decided "demo track-schmemo track", and released it as it was ... Carole King's first #1 hit!

http://www.history-of-rock.com/cookies.htm

http://www.history-of-rock.com/little_eva.htm

The Cookies later on wound up being Ray Charles backup singers, the Ray-lettes. Old joke - you couldn't be a Ray-lette unless you let Ray  


*** "Baby It's You", The Shirelles:

http://www.last.fm/music/The+Shirelles/+videos/+1-6gK6cHFYf2U


Funny how the instrumental break is pretty much just want George played on the guitar (and George Martin doubling on the piano?, I can't remember), and the fade out is exactly what John did on his version. Those boys knew something good when they heard it!


"Baby It's You", A Group Called Smith
And finally here's a version of the same song, "Baby It's You", by A Group Called Smith, in the late 60's. Turned out to be the highest charting version! ...

http://www.last.fm/music/Smith/+videos/+1-hCD5GpmFHUg

Can I say I think I might like it even better than John's vocals?




I love John,
I love Paul,
And George and Ringo,
I love them all!

Alexis
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 81 - 93
alexis
June 7, 2008, 9:43pm Report to Moderator

Getting Better
Posts
786
Posts Per Day
1.38
Quoted from Sandra
Air, water, fire, and something else. Or am I way off here?

Paul would be the air for me. John the fire. I don't know about the other two. I guess Ringo would be: other. Heh.


I didn't have any answers myself, but I like the way you went on them!

John definitely "Fire" ,and I like Paul being "Air" also. How about Ringo being "Earth"? What about George? Water? (He did sing "Wah Wah" on ? ATMP?)  


I love John,
I love Paul,
And George and Ringo,
I love them all!

Alexis
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 82 - 93
aspinall_lover
June 7, 2008, 9:48pm Report to Moderator

Getting Better
Posts
840
Gender
Female
Posts Per Day
6.24
Neil Aspinall.............of course, from this "aspinall lover"..............



"There might have been things I missed, but don't be unkind, it don't mean I'm blind, but there it is......"
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 83 - 93
Sandra
June 7, 2008, 10:46pm Report to Moderator

Moderators
Posts
5,538
Gender
Female
Posts Per Day
3.54
Quoted from alexis


I didn't have any answers myself, but I like the way you went on them!

John definitely "Fire" ,and I like Paul being "Air" also. How about Ringo being "Earth"? What about George? Water? (He did sing "Wah Wah" on ? ATMP?)  


At first I thought George would definitely be earth. Cuz he's, well, earthy! But then Ringo always seemed to be the most grounded and of this world. So I think earth suits him. Water goes through everything and is very other worldly in a way. It takes many shapes and can be very strong as well. Sort of like George!

Honestly, I have no idea what I'm talking about and I know it's off topic, so sorry. But I think it's interesting comparing them to ancient elements. It sort of fits the whole, everything came from them thing that Beatle obsessives innatley believe.  


Logged Offline
Private Message Reply: 84 - 93
alexis
June 7, 2008, 11:03pm Report to Moderator

Getting Better
Posts
786
Posts Per Day
1.38
Quoted from Sandra


At first I thought George would definitely be earth. Cuz he's, well, earthy! But then Ringo always seemed to be the most grounded and of this world. So I think earth suits him. Water goes through everything and is very other worldly in a way. It takes many shapes and can be very strong as well. Sort of like George!

Honestly, I have no idea what I'm talking about and I know it's off topic, so sorry. But I think it's interesting comparing them to ancient elements. It sort of fits the whole, everything came from them thing that Beatle obsessives inatley believe.  


Moi? Us?



I love John,
I love Paul,
And George and Ringo,
I love them all!

Alexis
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 85 - 93
Bill Harry
June 18, 2008, 8:34pm Report to Moderator
Special Member
Posts
186
Posts Per Day
0.86
God, I just wish the term 'The 5th Beatle' hadn't come into existence. The Beatles, as we all know them, were John, Paul, George and Ringo. There was no one else in the line-up. Brian Epstein managed them, George Martin recorded them, Pete Best and Stuart Sutcliffe were former members, but the Beatles were a quartet, there wasn't a fifth Beatle. Let's refer to Brian as their manager, to George as their recording manager, to Neil as their friend, to Pete and Stuart as former members and let's leave it at that.
If there were five Beatles playing together on stage, or recording together, let's all into the secret.
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 86 - 93
DaveRam
June 20, 2008, 10:39am Report to Moderator

Words Of Love
Posts
1,214
Posts Per Day
4.48
Surely the 5th Beatle is each and every FAN ? you don't have much of anything without that special ingredient


Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 87 - 93
Bill Harry
June 20, 2008, 10:49am Report to Moderator
Special Member
Posts
186
Posts Per Day
0.86
On the other hand there was John, Paul, George, Pete and Chas. Newby advertised as the Beatles direct from Hamburg who made such a terrific impact at Litherland Town Hall, but no one would suggest Chas as a fifth Beatle.
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 88 - 93
Andy Smith
June 21, 2008, 11:06pm Report to Moderator

Words Of Love
Posts
3,285
Posts Per Day
6.23
hey, Bill Harry is the 5th Beatle!!  



"sitting on a cornflake, waiting for the van to come."
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Windows Live Messenger Reply: 89 - 93
7 Pages « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 » All Recommend Thread
Print

DM's Beatles forums    Solo forums    Fifth Beatles and Merseybeat  ›  Who's the 5th Beatle?

DM's Beatles site - Top 100 Beatles sites

Powered by E-Blah Forum Software 10.3.5 © 2001-2008