Which of the above hasn't most matched the quality of their work in the bands mentioned.

Mick Jagger's solo stuff is nauseating, Roger Water's doesn't stand up to his Floyd stuff showing he WASN'T the entire genius behind them, Robbie Robertson? I don't think I've ever heard his solo stuff. Pete Townshend has like 2 or 3 good solo songs and the other two I don't care about. As for Paul, well, I think his solo stuff stands up the best in his early days, but I'm probably biased about that.

Who has not been disappointing as a solo artist after a carreer in a band, except Robbie Williams?

Quoted from Bobber

Who has not been disappointing as a solo artist after a carreer in a band, except Robbie Williams?

It hurts to say but Phil Collins?

Quoted from kevin_b

It hurts to say but Phil Collins?

Ouch. Still, I liked the man better in his Genesis-days. But it's true he was more succesfull as a solo-artist, commercially and sadly.

I'm not a big Genesis fan--but I like Phil's drumming alot in Genesis.  I think Peter Gabriel also became much better post Genesis.  

Just wait for A BIG BOX SET that Macca deserves, then proceed to tell me that he's the biggest dissapointment as a solo artist.

I mean come on, a single greatest hits Wings compilation cd alone would kick those other guys' butts.

Roger Waters shouldn't be on there. Pros And Cons Of Hitchhiking is a brilliant collection of enlish blues. One gets the feeling listening to it that he realized he could have just done what he did in Floyd but then he just said, f*** it, I'll do whatever the hell I feel like! So, he chucked out the synthesizers and amplifiers and voice boxes, brought in an all-female du-wop band, Eric Clapton, and a blues concert pianist and then poured his goddamn heart out. Radio KAOS was a bit cheesy (VERY cheesy as a matter of fact) but enthralling nonetheless, and Amused To Death is a great political album! I think that Nick Mason should be on that list. Profiles was alright but Fictitious Sports was freaking horrendous! I feel Mick Jagger's solo work, well lacking, is quite good. Phil Collins disappoints me when I look back on the days of Genesis.

Robbie Robertson and Pete Townshend have put out great solo material. Paul has too. This is another stupid poll, but given the author, not surprising.  Why not spin it and ask who has had the best solo output of these?

he said she said?

Quoted from pc31

he said she said?

and we are all together...

Robbie Roberrtson had an excellent solo album, as did Townshend.  And I'd say Sting did better solo than with the Police?  maybe

I Havent heard any of that music except for Pauls

Quoted from MagicAlex

I mean come on, a single greatest hits Wings compilation cd alone would kick those other guys' butts.

How about this:

Quoted from juniorsfarm

is another stupid poll, but given the author, not surprising.

Meowww!! Someone's woken up all dumpy and gropey this morning!!