Can anyone tell me if the vocals on Hey Bulldog include Ringo doing harmonies and the 'dog sounds' and following laughter, or is it Paul? I did read that it is Paul, but it sounds just like Ringo to me. If it were Paul, does anyone think that sometimes Paul's backing vocals sound like Ringo singing? Originally I thought that it was Ringo doing backing vocals on Old Brown Shoe, but now I know that it is Paul. Can anyone enlighten me?

Here, check this out. Should tell you everything you need to know about 'Hey Bulldog' and to find the others, just press "songs" at the top of the page.

http://stevesbeatles.com/songs/hey_bulldog.asp

The vocals, dog noises and shouting etc is by John and Paul - you can see them recording it in the Lady Madonna promo video (which was later re-edited to tie in with the actual Hey Bulldog vocals).

yea, i downloaded a video of it and they actually show them laughing and mess. its pretty funny.

p8ntball370, thanks for the info. So, Ringo figures on it but Paul does the vocals. Funny, I'm sure that Paul sometimes took his vocal approach from Ringo. Just seems to sound far more like Ringo than Paul to me.