Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Forum Login
Login Name: Create a new account
Password:     Forgot password

DM's Beatles forums    Beatles forums    Songs  ›  "Mother Natures Son" vs "Child of Nature" Moderators: Sandra, BlueMeanie, harihead

 Which song really belonged on the album?
Mother Nature's Son (4 votes)
57.14%
Child of Nature (3 votes)
42.86%
7 Votes Total Last vote September 14, 2007, 10:48am by pc31
You must login or register to be allowed to participate in this poll

"Mother Natures Son" vs "Child of Nature"  This thread currently has 233 views. Print
1 Pages 1 Recommend Thread
Buttmunker
September 13, 2007, 2:43pm Report to Moderator
Getting Better
Posts
300
Posts Per Day
0.65
Both songs were up for the inclusion of "The White Album," but, for some reason, Paul's "Mother Nature's Son" won out.  John's "Child of Nature" lyrics were too close to Paul's song.

Child of Nature later reappeared on John Lennon's solo album, "Imagine," with new lyrics, called "Jealous Guy."

Personally, I liked John's song better (heard it on "The White Album Acoustic Demos"), it had a better rhythm.  How did Paul win that battle?  Did John simply relent and say, "okay, Paul," or did George Martin veto John's song in favor of Paul's?
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message
BlueMeanie
September 13, 2007, 3:37pm Report to Moderator

Board Moderator
Posts
6,388
Gender
Male
Posts Per Day
8.45
Child Of Nature was incomplete, which is why it never appeared on The White Album. It was also tried during the Let It Be sessions.

To be honest, I don't even think Child Of Nature made it to the studio. I've just been looking through all my White Album boots and cannot find a single take. Can't find it on BootlegZone either. And it's not listed in Lewisohn.


I just want you to reassure him - talk to him, make him see the error of his ways. Then I'll hit him.
Logged Offline
Private Message Reply: 1 - 7
Andy Smith
September 13, 2007, 10:17pm Report to Moderator

Words Of Love
Posts
3,519
Posts Per Day
5.56
Quoted from BlueMeanie


To be honest, I don't even think Child Of Nature made it to the studio. I've just been looking through all my White Album boots and cannot find a single take. Can't find it on BootlegZone either. And it's not listed in Lewisohn.


I don't think so either, i only know of the Esher version they recorded &
i think they played it in the Twickanham sessions. It's a wondeful song and
the lyrics were very good.
Mother Nature's Son is a great one as well, hard choice to pick though.




HAPPY 40TH BIRTHDAY TO THE WHITE ALBUM! you say its your birthday!
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Windows Live Messenger Reply: 2 - 7
tkitna
September 14, 2007, 12:22am Report to Moderator

I'm a Moondog,,,,,are you?
Words Of Love
Posts
3,927
Gender
Male
Posts Per Day
2.26
I think 'Mothers Natures Son' is a very underrated tune. Its always been a Beatle favorite of mine and I like it a lot better than 'Child Of Nature'.


http://com1.runboard.com/bthemoondogs                        
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 3 - 7
pc31
September 14, 2007, 10:47am Report to Moderator

rockabilly rules!!!!!
Special Member
Posts
9,208
Gender
Male
Posts Per Day
5.25
bcuz you are a paul fan...i like johns better becuz i b a john fan...


Logged Offline
Site E-mail Private Message AIM YIM Windows Live Messenger Reply: 4 - 7
tkitna
September 14, 2007, 10:56am Report to Moderator

I'm a Moondog,,,,,are you?
Words Of Love
Posts
3,927
Gender
Male
Posts Per Day
2.26
You beez speaking the truth my friend


http://com1.runboard.com/bthemoondogs                        
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 5 - 7
Andy Smith
September 14, 2007, 8:49pm Report to Moderator

Words Of Love
Posts
3,519
Posts Per Day
5.56
I think both songs are brilliant!  



HAPPY 40TH BIRTHDAY TO THE WHITE ALBUM! you say its your birthday!
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Windows Live Messenger Reply: 6 - 7
Pasta Cheif
September 14, 2007, 11:41pm Report to Moderator

Getting Better
Posts
295
Posts Per Day
0.57
Child of Nature I really like. Actually both songs, but if it comes to choice then I'll pick CON.


"Dont take life seriously, you'll never get out of it alive"
Logged Offline
E-mail Private Message Reply: 7 - 7
1 Pages 1 Recommend Thread
Print

DM's Beatles forums    Beatles forums    Songs  ›  "Mother Natures Son" vs "Child of Nature"

DM's Beatles site - Top 100 Beatles sites

Powered by E-Blah Forum Software 10.3.5 © 2001-2008