Quoted from fendertele

indeed my apologies i think i went off on one :S

Quoted from mr kite

George in the wrong group !!!

No No No , how can anyone consider The Beatles without George , so he was`nt as a strong song writer as John and Paul but arnt those 2 the greatest song writers ever in pop music [ cant hear any arguements on that bit on here ]
Four lads from Liverpool ruled the world , not 3 of them and that quiet one, is it .
Check out how many young people today who are George fans just oh this Forum , and some old ones to  

My thoughts exactly.

Quoted from fendertele

imho he's wrote some good songs but nothing amazing.

That's your opinion and I respect it, but to say he could only write a few good songs a year is ridiculous.
In the Beatles, the Wilburys, and solo, I think he has proven himself as a great song writer.
I feel like I can hear his heart and soul in his music, and that's something I can't say about a lot
of McCartney's music (no matter how much I love it).

The Beatles without any of the four is not The Beatles.
(I just got a bit of Deja Vu from this exact same argument over Ringo)