What of these unreleased Beatles songs do you want to hear most? (if anyone knows any others let me know and I can add it in)

I'd love to hear them all, but I went with 'Love You To (Take 1)' just for giggles and such.

I'll pick "Carnival Of Light", since it's here, but I'd love to hear the 28 minute version of "Helter Skelter"!

"Etcetera," which is the most promising sounding song of the lot. Paul apparently wrote it for Marianne Faithfull in 1968, but the tape has been lost.

http://www.richieunterberger.com/rumored.html

I agree on "Love You To", it'd be so cool to hear that take. But I think "Carnival Of Light" comes first. I mean, a somewhat complete or at least complete to The Beatles "song" or perhaps "collage" from Pepper time not being released? What ARE they thinking? As much acclaim Pepper has got, you think every shred of anything related to it would have been out by now. If it was Sir George Martin who vetoed it, then thats another regret besides the Strawberry Fields single release. But beggars can't be choosers, so I'd take any of them really.

Quoted from ringostarr1983

What of these unreleased Beatles songs do you want to hear most? (if anyone knows any others let me know and I can add it in)

you need Helter Skelter Take 3 on the poll! that's what I want to hear!

and what's all the hoopla about Love You To take 1????

George Martin on why the long version of "Helter Skelter" was left off Anthology 3:

Perhaps the Holy Grail of unheard Beatles outtakes is this legendary 27-minute version of "Helter Skelter," at a session also producing ten- and twelve-minute versions. In The Beatles Recording Sessions,  Mark Lewisohn noted that "each take developed into a tight and concisely played jam with long instrumental passages." The four-and-a-half-minute edit of take 2 on Anthology 3  lowered expectations, however, as even this truncated version both veered on tedium and was far inferior to the final arrangement, with its dragging tempo and rote blues-rock guitar licks. Explaining why a longer version was not chosen for the Anthology CD compilations in a 1995 Dutch interview (as seen in the bonus disc of the bootlegged director's cut of the Anthology documentary), George Martin was blunt: "I think it gets boring." His elaboration perhaps gave away more than he would have liked about the core philosophy behind the Anthology collections: "In making these records, my consideration has been to put in works that are interesting to the majority of people. Not to Beatle fanatics. And I have to look at the public as a broad, interesting thing. And I don't want to put anything that people are going to say"—here he yawned for emphasis—"'I wonder when this is gonna finish.' And that's what that would do. Now, there are the hardcore Beatle fanatics who would love to have this. But they already have it on bootleg." Most Beatles fanatics love George Martin for what he did with the group, but most could have told him that he was wrong—we don't have it on bootleg, as none of the long versions have ever made it onto that format. (In fact, the over-halved edit of take 2 on Anthology 3 is the only version of "Helter Skelter" from this session to have made it into circulation.)

http://www.richieunterberger.com/rumored.html

Quoted from Mellotroniac

I agree on "Love You To", it'd be so cool to hear that take. But I think "Carnival Of Light" comes first. I mean, a somewhat complete or at least complete to The Beatles "song" or perhaps "collage" from Pepper time not being released? What ARE they thinking? As much acclaim Pepper has got, you think every shred of anything related to it would have been out by now. If it was Sir George Martin who vetoed it, then thats another regret besides the Strawberry Fields single release. But beggars can't be choosers, so I'd take any of them really.

George Martin didn't veto 'Carnival Of Light', George Harrison did. Here's a description of it:

"the song included "distorted, hypnotic drum and organ sounds, a distorted lead guitar, the sound of a church organ, various effects (water gargling was one) and, perhaps most intimidating of all, John Lennon and McCartney screaming dementedly and bawling aloud random phrases like "Are you alright?" and "Barcelona!"

If you want to listen to the sound of an Elephant arriving through the birth canal of a donkey, fine!

Some discussion here: http://www.dmbeatles.com/forums/m-1112096590/

i'd like to hear to all of them! awww!

It seems that the song that Beatle fans most want to hear is 'Carnival Of Light'. You know, I bet everyone is going to be very disappointed in this. It's nothing more than a 15 minute improvised freak out. Done in one take. That's all the time they spent on it. I'd like to hear it, but I'm not expecting much. Same goes for Helter Skelter.

"Carnival Of Light" sounds as though it was recorded in the same haphazard / spontaneous way as "Two Virgins," which doesn't sound very encouraging to me, either, although if a bootleg of the thing appeared I'd be the first guy (on this continent, anyway) to grab a copy. The five minute edit of "Helter Skelter" on Anthology 3 doesn't bode well for the remaining forty five or so unreleased minutes of that song's takes, either.

I am honestly not that interested in hearing Carnival of Light. It sounds like another Revolution No. 9 to me.

All for love.

Quoted from Mairi

I am honestly not that interested in hearing Carnival of Light. It sounds like another Revolution No. 9 to me.

I think it's even worse.