ADITL over MMT for me any day and every day... and I really like MMT. However, for me, ADITL is on a completely different level than MMT.
As for your Time Travel Test, Meanie, I'm afraid I have to politely disagree w/ your assessment on ADITL. Do I think it would sound ok if released today? Yes, absolutely. But would it do ok commercially? Not a chance. ADITL is not the kind of song/music the kids are listening to these days. IMO, it wouldn't have a snowball's chance in Hades of cracking the top 200 on the Billboard singles charts.