Ok. I'm having a rethink.
Overall the album, based on the source material (McCartney and POB), would be quite simple and stripped back. It might end up being closer to what they envisaged with Let it Be. But with the potential to be tighter.
That being my vision, I'm not sure My Sweet Lord, as big a hit as it was, would fit so well. It's a song that suits bigger production, lots of gospel-like background vocals for instance. And given John's attitude at the time I reckon he would have vetoed George's Krishna songs anyway.
So I'd suggest substituting in Apple Scruffs from ATMP. It's a simple but light hearted and catchy song. Also has a Beatle related theme.
With this idea for the album I agree with Nim that Oo You fits at riff and vocal etc. so I'd instead drop Teddy Boy, which I was never that keen on.
With this I'd rejig the order a bit
What is Life
Oo You
I Found Out
Junk
Remember
That Lovely Linda
Isolation
Maybe I'm Amazed
Every Night
Love
Apple Scruffs
Mother
That Would Be Something
God
Not sure it'd be the Beatles most commercially accessible album. Not a lot of uptempo tunes. But it'd do pretty well on critical acclaim and buck the trend toward stadium rock that was developing. Plus it has a few classic tracks (Maybe I'm Amazed, Love, Mother, What is Life)