Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[tkitna]

Well the votes are finally tallied. I took the top threee songs per album (YS I took one and the White Album I took 6). We could make this a double CD or rank this list to get down to a single. Some interesting choices too. Theres a few I never thought would make it through, but here goes-

Finals
1. Please Please Me
2. Twist And Shout
3. I Saw Her Standing There
4. All My Loving
5. Don

[Lostio]

Hmm... Well, I must admit that I was also doing the 'general' ranking after seeing each one's rankings in each post and a few songs you put there got differente than mine, like:

Ticket To Ride - I got The Night Before instead
Martha My Dear - I got Mother Nature's Son instead
Golden Slumbers - I got Come Together instead

But still that looks like a mighty cool album and I would love to see it on stores.

One problem I see with it is that Golden Slumbers is not a good closer... I'm sure that this goes in chronological order, but I would put a more "climactic" song there instead... like Across the universe or something (no, not the song )...

Anyway... looks cool. *thumbs up*

[tkitna]

Hmm... Well, I must admit that I was also doing the 'general' ranking after seeing each one's rankings in each post and a few songs you put there got differente than mine, like:

Ticket To Ride - I got The Night Before instead
Martha My Dear - I got Mother Nature's Son instead
Golden Slumbers - I got Come Together instead

But still that looks like a mighty cool album and I would love to see it on stores.

You might be right as the scores were tallied over about a two week time span and i'm sure more people voted in that time, but here's the numbers I came up with.

HELP              
1. Help - 60              
2. You

[tkitna]

One problem I see with it is that Golden Slumbers is not a good closer... I'm sure that this goes in chronological order, but I would put a more "climactic" song there instead... like Across the universe or something (no, not the song )...

Anyway... looks cool. *thumbs up*

Yeah, i definately agree with you about 'Golden Slumbers'. The working order can be messed with though and maybe some contest down the road can be used with a burnt CD of this list. I'll try to think of something.

[Lostio]

Well, here are the numbers I got:

HELP!
1. Help! - 84
2. You've Got To Hide Your Love Away - 93
3. The Night Before - 122
4. Yesterday - 129
5. Ticket To Ride - 136
6. You're Gonna Lose That Girl - 138
7. It's Only Love - 148
8. I Need You - 164
9. I've Just Seen A Face - 174
10. Another Girl - 191
11. Tell Me What You See - 241
12. You Like Me Too Much - 257
13. Act Naturally - 261
14. Dizzy Miss Lizzy - 276

ABBEY ROAD
1. Here Comes The Sun - 64
2. Something - 95
3. Come Together - 106
4. You Never Give Me Your Money - 116
5. Golden Slumbers - 121
6. Oh! Darling - 127
7. The End - 140
8. Carry That Weight - 151
9. I Want You (She's So Heavy) - 155
10. She Came In Through The Bathroom Window - 166
11. Polythene Pam - 177
12. Maxwell's Silver Hammer - 180
13. Octopus' Garden - 184
14. Because - 186
15. Mean Mr. Mustard - 187
16. Her Majesty - 239
17. Sun King - 281

WHITE ALBUM
1. Happiness Is A Warm Gun - 58
2. Blackbird - 63
3. Back In The USSR - 67
4. I Will - 77
5. Mother Nature's Son  - 78
6. Cry Baby Cry - 79
7. Dear Prudence - 80
8. Helter Skelter - 82
9. While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 86
10. Martha My Dear - 88
11. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da - 92
12. Julia - 107
13. Rocky Raccoon - 113
14. Birthday - 116
15. Sexy Sadie - 116
16. Honey Pie - 120
17. Savoy Truffle - 122
18. Glass Onion - 122
19. Piggies - 123
20. I'm So Tired - 127
21. Don't Pass Me By - 143
22. Revolution 1 - 147
23. Everybody's Got Something To Hide Except For Me And My Monkey - 148
24. Good Night - 149
25. The Continuing Story Of Bungalow Bill - 166
26. Yer Blues - 168
27. Why Don't We Do It In The Road? - 169
28. Long, Long, Long - 184
29. Wild Honey Pie - 216
30. Revolution 9 - 234

The ones that were tied in the White Album, I put on top the one I liked the most out of those ince it would be only the top 3 (in this case, top 6) that would count, anyway...

I did this while I was on vacation and I had nothing better to do.

[tkitna]

As my wife knows, I was premature as usual. I should use your list Lostio as I like those songs better anyways.  

[Lostio]

OK. Now the Golden Slumbers issue is fixed, too.