Hello - thanks for posting that video, very cool, love the comments on youtube too after it.
I agree with everyone's comments, TK - I'm with you, I remember "defending" them and their music so much more long ago and I too believe a voice from a singer is an instrument and have argued that the four of them used their voice instruments better than most bands every did , there still is something there that a group or band , all playing , is more fulfilling for me to listen too. Obviously there are exceptions, many great songs where no band is playing, maybe some engineered backing or whatever but the energy from a band playing is different. At least to me.
All great thoughts and comments